1.5Absolute and Comparative Advantage
16:19 September 5, 2023 6-question practice quiz
In this video
- 0:00Introduction of the Topic
- 1:03Absolute Advantage - An Example
- 2:05Absolute Advantage Defined
- 2:32Comparative Advantage - An Example
- 3:57Comparative Advantage Defined
- 4:50The Theory of Absolute Advantage - Example & Explanation
- 8:18The Theory of Absolute Advantage - Defined
- 9:13Why we can't always use the Theory of Absolute Advantage
- 10:13The Theory of Comparative Advantage - Defined
- 10:30The Theory of Comparative Advantage - Example & Explanation
- 14:08Recap of the Lesson
About this video
Read the transcript
For the better part of the last 75 years, the world has witnessed a global transformation, with increased trade and economic interdependence. Over that same period of time, economists have been creating increasingly convincing models of why that trade should be a good thing for all parties involved. However, in recent years, we've seen the world take a step back from this trend of globalization, driven by both political and economic issues, domestically and abroad. Some have gone so far as to argue that increased trade and globalization is actually bad for some of the nations involved in the transaction. All the while, the original economic theory, as convincing as ever, has never changed. Those ideas, absolute and comparative advantage, are the topic of today's video. Hi, I'm Mr. Racine. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.
In order to introduce the concepts of absolute and comparative advantage, let's first introduce two well-known brothers. The first is LeBron James. You all know LeBron James. The second is his lesser-known younger brother, Scotty James. This is him. He's imaginary, and for the purposes of this video, only LeBron James plays basketball, and Scotty James mows lawns.
So LeBron has a pretty big mansion, and he needs to have his lawn mowed. We can consider how much time it takes each brother to mow the lawn. LeBron is pretty big and strong; he can mow his lawn in two hours. It's a big lawn, you know; it's a big mansion. Scotty is smaller, but he's gritty, and can mow the lawn in five hours. Okay, so LeBron is better at mowing the lawn; he can do it in fewer hours. In this case, we say that LeBron has an absolute advantage in mowing the lawn. An economy, or a person, has an absolute advantage in producing a good or service when they can do it using fewer resources. It takes LeBron two hours to mow the lawn; it takes Scotty five hours to mow the lawn. So LeBron can do it using fewer resources. He can do it better; he has an absolute advantage.
So why would he ever ask Scotty to mow his lawn? We need to consider the opportunity cost of the time it takes each brother to mow the lawn. Opportunity cost is the value of the next best option that is foregone when someone makes a choice. Here, we need to consider: what would the brothers be doing if they weren't using their time to mow the lawn? Well, in LeBron's case, if he weren't mowing his lawn for two hours, he could go and play a basketball game, which, at his current contract rate, I have estimated at earning him $542,317.07. So in essence, LeBron is foregoing half a million dollars to mow his lawn. What is Scotty's opportunity cost of mowing the lawn? Well, if he didn't mow the lawn, his next best option would have been to go and work at McDonald's, where he could have earned $7.50 an hour, for a whopping grand total of $37.50.
So the opportunity cost to LeBron of mowing the lawn is half a million dollars, and the opportunity cost to Scotty is $37.50. The opportunity cost is lower to Scotty for mowing the lawn; he's giving up less by performing the service. So we can say that Scotty James has a comparative advantage in mowing the lawn. A person or an economy has a comparative advantage in producing a good or a service when they can produce it at a lower opportunity cost. So in this case, even though LeBron has an absolute advantage in mowing lawns (he can do it faster), there's still an opportunity for trade, because Scotty has the comparative advantage: he can mow the lawn at a lower opportunity cost. How much money would LeBron need to pay Scotty in order to make it worthwhile for both of them? Well, more than $37.50, because this is what Scotty would have earned at McDonald's, and less than $542,317.07, because if LeBron has to pay more than that, he might as well skip the basketball game and just mow the lawn himself.
So, I promise you, this has an economic application. Let's take a look at it. Let's now transfer these concepts to two different economies: Baconistan and France. Each economy makes two different goods: bacon and French toast. For the purposes of this model, we'll assume that each economy possesses identical factors of production (the same amount of land, labor, and capital), but each economy has different productive capabilities. If Baconistan were to put all of its factors of production into making bacon, they would produce 10 units of bacon in a year. If they were to produce only French toast, they would produce five units of French toast. We can plot this information on a production possibilities curve. Assuming constant opportunity cost, we can draw the rest of the PPC like this, which suggests Baconistan can also produce eight units of bacon and one unit of French toast, six units of bacon and two units of French toast, et cetera, et cetera. If France were to put all of its resources into the production of bacon, they could produce four units of bacon in a year, and if they only made French toast, they could make 12 units of French toast. We can plot these points on the same diagram and extrapolate the constant-cost PPC in a similar fashion.
Okay, from the diagram and from our table, which economy has the absolute advantage in the production of bacon? What am I asking? Which economy is better at making bacon, or which economy can produce bacon using fewer resources? Since each economy has identical factors of production, if Baconistan can make more units of bacon, clearly each unit of bacon requires fewer units of inputs. So Baconistan has the absolute advantage in the production of bacon. By the same logic, France has the absolute advantage in the production of French toast. On exam questions, if an economy or person can make something in a shorter amount of time, or using fewer resources, or they can make more of something in the same amount of time or with the same amount of resources, then they have what we call an absolute advantage. On a PPC, if an economy's PPC line is further out on one axis, then they have the absolute advantage in the production of the good associated with that axis.
So France has the absolute advantage in producing French toast, so they should produce French toast, and Baconistan has the absolute advantage in producing bacon, so they should make bacon. If France makes only French toast, they can make 12 units of French toast, and if Baconistan makes only bacon, they produce 10 units of bacon. Now, if they trade, let's say, four units of bacon for four units of French toast, then France would wind up with eight units of French toast and four units of bacon, and Baconistan would wind up with four units of French toast and six units of bacon. But those points fall outside of each economy's respective production possibilities curve. Now each economy is able to consume at a point beyond its production possibilities frontier, beyond the level that they would be able to produce by themselves without trade. According to the theory of absolute advantage, if an economy or person has an absolute advantage in the production of a good, then by specializing in the production of that good, they can engage in trade and enable themselves to consume at a point beyond their production possibilities curve. It's amazing!
"Hey, so great," you say, "but this only works when each economy has an absolute advantage in the production of a good. What if one economy is just really good at producing everything? Clearly, then, there would be no incentive for them to trade with other economies." Well, no. David Ricardo developed a further theory to explain why economies might still engage in trade, even in the case that one economy held the absolute advantage in the production of every good. This theory is called the theory of comparative advantage.
Okay, so let's examine two more economies: Fastville and Slowtown. Again, each economy has identical factors of production, and they produce only two goods: Xboxes and televisions. If Fastville produces only televisions, they could produce 20 televisions, and if they produce only Xboxes, they can produce 10 Xboxes. So their constant-cost PPC would look like this. And if Slowtown produced only TVs, they could produce 12 TVs, and if they produced only Xboxes, they could produce three Xboxes. So their PPC looks like this. So Fastville has the absolute advantage in the production of both TVs and Xboxes. They can produce more, meaning they can produce each using fewer resources. So we can't use the theory of absolute advantage to explain why these economies might trade, because Fastville is better at making everything.
So here, we need to apply the theory of comparative advantage. The theory of comparative advantage states that if an economy specializes in the production of a good in which they have a comparative advantage, then they can engage in trade and still consume at a point beyond their production possibilities curve. Let's look at how this works. Remember, in the case of the PPC, opportunity cost refers to the amount of good B that must be sacrificed in order to produce one more unit of good A. So what is the opportunity cost of Xboxes for Fastville? What am I really asking here? We're saying: if Fastville produces one more Xbox, how many televisions do they need to give up?
So if you're quick and mathematically inclined, you might be able to look at this PPC and just eyeball it. But I'm dumb, and I need a foolproof way to answer these questions, and here's how I do it. I know that for Fastville, the opportunity cost of 10 Xboxes is 20 TVs. All their resources put towards Xboxes could produce 10 Xboxes. If those resources weren't producing Xboxes, what would they be producing? TVs. How many TVs could they produce? 20. The opportunity cost of 10 Xboxes is 20 TVs. We can then apply some algebra kung fu to make this number equal to one. Wow. So for Fastville, the opportunity cost of one Xbox is two TVs. For Slowtown, the opportunity cost of three Xboxes is 12 TVs. Using the same technique, the opportunity cost of one Xbox is four TVs. When Fastville produces Xboxes, it's giving up two TVs. When Slowtown produces Xboxes, it's giving up four TVs. The opportunity cost of producing Xboxes is lower for Fastville; they're giving up fewer TVs when they produce Xboxes, so they have a comparative advantage in the production of Xboxes. So Fastville should produce Xboxes.
Since we've already done calculations for each economy's opportunity cost of producing Xboxes in terms of TVs, it's easy to calculate the opportunity cost of producing TVs. We can just take the inverse of the opportunity cost of Xboxes, or one divided by the opportunity cost of producing Xboxes. So for Fastville, the opportunity cost of producing one TV is just one over two, or half of an Xbox. And for Slowtown, the opportunity cost of producing one TV is one over four, or one fourth of an Xbox. One fourth is less than one half; look it up. So Slowtown has a lower opportunity cost in producing TVs, so therefore they have a comparative advantage in the production of TVs. So according to the theory of comparative advantage, Slowtown should produce TVs, and Fastville should produce Xboxes.
In this case, Slowtown would produce 12 TVs and Fastville would produce 10 Xboxes. They could then engage in trade, let's say three Xboxes for nine TVs. This would then leave Slowtown with three TVs and three Xboxes, and Fastville would get nine TVs and seven Xboxes. And again, both economies are consuming outside their production possibilities curves, even though Fastville has an absolute advantage in the production of both goods. This is why the theory of comparative advantage is even more compelling in explaining why we would expect to see all economies engage in trade for mutual benefit.
Okay, so this has been the theory of comparative advantage. These are the ideas we talked about today. One: an economy or a person has an absolute advantage in the production of a good or service when they can produce it using fewer resources. Two: an economy or person has a comparative advantage in producing a good or service when they can produce it at a lower opportunity cost. Three: the theory of absolute advantage says that if an economy has an absolute advantage in the production of a good, they can specialize in the production of that good and engage in trade, thereby enabling them to consume beyond their production possibilities curve. Four: the theory of comparative advantage says economies don't even need to have an absolute advantage in the production of a good. As long as you are able to produce a good at a lower opportunity cost, if you specialize in the production of that good and engage in trade, all economies can still benefit and consume beyond their production possibilities curve.
Okay, after you've taken a minute to absorb this information, I have two different follow-up videos for you. If you're taking AP or university-level intro economics, check out my solving absolute and comparative advantage video, which analyzes the three different types of questions you could get on this and walks you through the steps of solving them. If you're on an IB track, check out my evaluating and solving comparative advantage questions video, which includes some similar problem-solving techniques, but also evaluates some shortcomings of the model for potential IB final paper questions. Hope to see you there.
UNIT 1 More in Fundamental Economic Concepts
10:48
1.1 Scarcity, Choice and Opportunity Cost
9:26
1.2 Factors of Production
10:22
1.3 Economic Systems
15:13
1.4a The Production Possibilities Curve
16:33
1.4b Opportunity Cost and the PPF
16:19
NOW PLAYING
1.5 Absolute and Comparative Advantage
12:46
1.5a Answering AP and University Level Comparative Advantage Questions