2.5Simultaneous Shifts to Supply and Demand
12:17 October 23, 2023 6-question practice quiz
In this video
About this video
Read the transcript
Last video, we posed the question of why the price of N95 masks and hand sanitizer skyrocketed at the beginning of 2020. The answer is obvious: it was COVID. But we didn't satisfactorily answer the question in the framework of supply and demand. In reality, this price increase had to do with the simultaneous shift of the supply of these goods and the demand for these goods, which is the topic of today's video. I'm Mr. Racine. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.
Last video, we looked at what happens to equilibrium price and equilibrium quantity if there's a shift to supply or to demand. As long as only supply or demand is shifting, and demand is downward sloping and supply is upward sloping, we'll always be able to predict the impact on price and quantity of a shift to supply or demand. For example, if demand increases, we know that we expect equilibrium price to increase and equilibrium quantity to increase as well. But what if both supply and demand shift at the same time?
For example, what if there's an increase in the demand for university textbooks because more students are enrolling in college, and at the same time there's an increase in the supply of textbooks because there's a decrease in the cost of using printing presses, one of the inputs into the production of textbooks? In this case, what do we expect to happen to price and quantity? Well, it's possible that we see a shift that looks like this, where quantity increases and price increases. But then again, we could also see an increase to supply and demand that looks more like this, where quantity increases but price decreases.
So the quick answer is: when both supply and demand shift, we can say for certain what happens to either price or quantity, but we're never going to know for sure what happens to both. In this case, an increase in supply and demand increases equilibrium quantity, but equilibrium price could go up or it could go down. Whether it goes up or down depends upon the relative size of the increase in demand and supply.
Okay, so I have two different ways to think about simultaneous shifts to supply and demand. One is more concept-based, and one is more visual, graphical-based. Choose which one works best for you. If the first one isn't making any sense, then skip ahead to the second one. If neither of them make any sense, then, I don't know, go check out Mr. Clifford's channel.
Okay, so this first method requires you to understand the individual impacts of shifts to supply or demand on price and quantity. By themselves: if only demand increases, price increases and quantity increases. If only demand decreases, price falls and quantity falls. If only supply increases, price falls and quantity increases. And if only supply decreases, price goes up and quantity falls.
Okay, so we can apply this information to think about what happens when there is a simultaneous shift to supply and demand. If demand and supply both increase at the same time, we can think about the individual impacts of the increase in demand and the increase in supply. An increase in demand pushes price up and pushes equilibrium quantity up. An increase in supply pushes equilibrium quantity up and equilibrium price down. Both the increase in demand and the increase in supply are pushing to increase equilibrium quantity, but the increase in demand is pushing equilibrium price up and the increase in supply is pushing equilibrium price down. So these two shifts are pushing price in opposite directions. Because both the increase in demand and the increase in supply are pushing to increase equilibrium quantity, we know for sure that equilibrium quantity is definitely going to increase. But price could go up or down, depending upon which force is stronger: the upward pressure on price caused by the increase in demand, or the downward pressure on price caused by the increase in supply.
Similarly, if both supply and demand decrease, the decrease in demand is driving price down and equilibrium quantity down, and the decrease in supply is driving equilibrium quantity down but equilibrium price up. Both of these changes are pushing equilibrium quantity down, so equilibrium quantity is definitely going to fall. But the decrease in supply is pushing prices up and the decrease in demand is pushing prices down, so price could go up or down. The impact is uncertain.
If demand increases and supply decreases, the increase in demand is pushing quantity and price up, and the decrease in supply is pushing price up and quantity down. Both of these changes, the increase in demand and the decrease in supply, are pushing equilibrium price up, but they have opposing forces on equilibrium quantity. The increase in demand makes quantity want to increase, but the decrease in supply makes quantity want to decrease, so the impact on quantity is indeterminate, or uncertain.
Finally, if there's an increase in supply and a decrease in demand, the decrease in demand drives price down and quantity down. The increase in supply drives price down and quantity up. Both of these changes are driving price down, so price is definitely going to fall. But the decrease in demand makes quantity want to fall, and the increase in supply makes quantity want to rise, so the impact on quantity is indeterminate.
So this is a concept-based approach. For a lot of students, this makes sense. If you totally hated it, check out the graphical approach. The graphical approach uses (surprise) a graph.
Here's the supply and demand for books. Here's equilibrium price; here's equilibrium quantity. If both supply and demand increase, we know that this means supply must shift to the right and demand also must shift to the right. So this means that our new equilibrium point must be somewhere in here, in this quadrant. It's not possible for our new equilibrium point to be anywhere over here if supply and demand are increasing. So we know that the new equilibrium point must be somewhere in here, and if that's the case, then the new equilibrium quantity must be some level greater than the original equilibrium quantity here. Equilibrium price, however, could go up, for example if the new equilibrium point were here, or it could go down, if the new equilibrium point were down here. So when both supply and demand increase, we know that the new equilibrium point must be in this area somewhere in here, which indicates that equilibrium quantity must increase, but equilibrium price could go up or could go down.
Similarly, if both supply and demand fall, we know then that our new equilibrium point must be somewhere in this quadrant right here. We can't wind up here, or here, or here, because this would require either supply or demand, or both, to increase. So then we know that if our new equilibrium point is somewhere in here, this means that equilibrium quantity must be some quantity lower than our original equilibrium quantity. So equilibrium quantity is definitely going to fall, but price could go up or it could go down. So when both supply and demand fall, equilibrium quantity definitely falls, but equilibrium price could go up or could go down.
If supply decreases and demand increases, then we must wind up somewhere up here for our new equilibrium point. This suggests, then, that equilibrium price must go up; there's no equilibrium point in this quadrant up here where price doesn't go up. But we could arrive at a higher equilibrium quantity than our original equilibrium, or a lower equilibrium quantity, depending upon the relative size of the shifts of supply and demand. So when demand increases and supply decreases, price definitely goes up, but the impact on quantity is indeterminate.
And finally, when supply increases and demand decreases, our new equilibrium point must be somewhere down here, which indicates that equilibrium price must fall, but equilibrium quantity could increase or it could decrease. The impact on quantity is indeterminate.
Okay, so we now have all of the tools that we need to satisfactorily explain why, at the beginning of 2020, we saw such a massive spike in the price of items such as hand sanitizer and N95 masks. We know that the world became aware of COVID at the beginning of 2020, and shortly thereafter there was a massive spike in demand for things like face masks and hand sanitizer, 'cause we really had no idea what this thing was. I remember I was disinfecting my mail in my garage for months.
But at the same time, the supply of things like N95 masks and hand sanitizer also decreased greatly, for a number of reasons. China, which is one of the world's leading manufacturers of PPE, stopped the export of all of those types of goods to keep them in the country and try and deal with the pandemic themselves, effectively decreasing the supply for other nations. Also, the factories which were responsible for producing many of these goods shut down as the world tried to figure out what was going on, and we kind of closed everything temporarily. So it was this increase in demand and simultaneous decrease in supply that, we can say quite confidently, drove the prices of N95 masks and hand sanitizer through the roof at the beginning of 2020.
Okay, so this has been simultaneous shifts to supply and demand. When both supply and demand shift, we only know for certain what happens to price or quantity, but never both. When both demand and supply increase, we definitely know that quantity is going to increase, but price could increase or decrease. When both supply and demand decrease, equilibrium quantity definitely falls, but the impact on equilibrium price is indeterminate. When demand increases and supply decreases, equilibrium price certainly goes up, but the impact on quantity is indeterminate. And finally, when supply increases and demand decreases, we will definitely see a decrease in price, but equilibrium quantity could go up or it could go down.
Okay, next lesson we're going to be looking at the concept of marginal utility and marginal benefit as it applies to the downward-sloping demand curve. It's a really important concept in economics that a lot of students tend to gloss over, so be sure not to miss it. I'll see you there.
UNIT 2 More in Supply and Demand
19:01
2.1 Demand Introduced
16:05
2.1a Non-Price Determinants of Demand
13:01
2.2 Supply Introduced
12:18
2.2a Non-Price Determinants of Supply
7:17
2.3 Supply and Demand in Equilibrium
10:38
2.4 Shifts to Supply and Demand
12:17
NOW PLAYING
2.5 Simultaneous Shifts to Supply and Demand
18:26
2.6a Marginal Utility, Marginal Benefit, and Demand
13:57
2.6b Marginal Cost and Supply
11:31
2.7 Consumer Surplus, Producer Surplus, and Social Surplus
8:45
2.8 Allocative Efficiency