5.1Introduction to Market Failure
9:02 August 30, 2026 6-question practice quiz
In this video
About this video
Read the transcript
So far, we've assumed the market to be this magical place where buyers and sellers meet, price signals work seamlessly, total social surplus is maximized, allocative efficiency is achieved, marginal benefit equals marginal cost, everybody lives happily ever after. Except, what if it doesn't? What if the market completely drops the ball? That brings us to today's topic, introduction to market failure. I'm Mr. Racine. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.
Market failure happens when the free market fails to allocate resources efficiently. So far, we've said that allocative efficiency occurs when marginal benefit equals marginal cost: the benefit of consuming that last unit is equal to the cost of producing that last unit. But in the real world, transactions don't happen in a vacuum, and markets can break down. When market failure strikes, for some reason, the quantity that the free market produces is not allocatively efficient. Marginal benefit doesn't equal marginal cost, and either too little or too much of the good is produced. To illustrate the concept of market failure, let's follow three upstanding young citizens, Evan, Seth, and McLovin. The boys start their day in high school. Seth, Evan, and McLovin are paying attention in their class so that they can graduate, go to college, I don't know, maybe meet a girl. That's their private benefit, right? The reason that they go to school is the benefit that it brings to them. They gain an education, they'll be able to go to college, and someday they'll be able to get a better job. But at the same time, society is benefiting from these boys being in school, because having people in school leads to having a more educated workforce, lower crime rates, and a whole other host of benefits which have been correlated with a highly educated society. That external social benefit to society is what we're going to call a positive externality.
But Seth couldn't give two about the fact that his being in high school has the potential to like lower crime rates for America. He's not waking up at 7:00 a.m. out of pure altruism for society. Seth makes decisions according to his private benefit, what's good for him and not like what's good for society, right? So, the private market by itself, we'll see, is going to lead to too little education being provided, which is why most economies have some form of public education available. We'll dive into positive externalities, where somebody external to the transaction is somehow positively impacted by the transaction, even though they're not directly a buyer or a seller.
Fast forward to the evening. The boys are now at a house party. Everyone there is having a great time enjoying themselves probably a little bit too much. Like the happiness, the enjoyment that people are getting from the party is their private benefit, the people who are like involved in the consumption of the party. But the party at the same time is blasting loud music into the night. There's drunk teenagers who are like throwing garbage onto the neighbor's lawn, and somebody accidentally like kicks a hole in the driveway.
Seth and Evan and McLovin, they don't pay for the neighbor's like loss of sleep due to the loud music. Like it doesn't affect them in that way. The neighbor is external to the party itself, but they're still being affected. The party in this example is a negative externality. Somebody outside of the transaction is negatively being affected by the party. And as a result, too many parties are going to be thrown in the neighborhood. We'll dive into what happens when somebody external to supply and demand is negatively impacted by a transaction when we look at negative externalities of production and negative externalities of consumption in a later video.
Okay, inside of the party, somebody gets out a giant unmonitored bowl of punch. It's non-excludable because like anybody who wants to can go up to the punch and drink it, but it's rivalrous in that there's a certain amount of punch that's actually available. Because everyone is thinking at the same time, if I don't drink this punch now, somebody else is going to, everybody rushes to drink the punch and nobody thinks to like preserve it or save some for later. Punch is what we call a common access resource, something that is available to all, but it will run out if everybody uses it.
And it suffers from what we call the tragedy of the commons where nobody maintains a publicly owned resource. More than the socially optimal quantity of punch is going to be consumed and it's going to run out. Too much is consumed in the case of common access resources. We'll dive into common access resources in a later video on common access resources. After the party gets busted, the three boys are walking down the street and fortunately for them, the street is like lit up by these streetlights so that they can see at night, right? That's nice. Streetlights are an example of a public good, a good that is non-rival. McLovin using the light so that he can see on the street like doesn't reduce the availability of the streetlight for Evan and Seth, and it's non-excludable. It's not possible to prevent people from using the streetlights once they're built. What do you think Seth's reaction would be if like somebody from the electric company came out and they said like, "Excuse me, you need to pay to use these streetlights, right?" He'd tell them to go jump in a lake, but probably with more colorful language. Because private companies can't easily charge money for people to use streetlights, they're not going to be willing to provide them by themselves and the free market is going to under-allocate resources to the provision of public goods, which is why very often governments provide them. We'll talk a lot more about public goods in our video on public goods.
Finally, think back to McLovin walking into the liquor store with his Hawaii ID. Now, fortunately for McLovin, there's a number of different liquor stores in the town and they're all competing with one another, which is what ensures that the cheap 12-pack of beer that he's trying to buy isn't too expensive. But, imagine if there was only one liquor store in the entire town or the entire state. Well, the owner of that store could charge practically any price that he wanted to, ripping poor McLovin off. But, when that liquor store owner decides to charge a higher price, he's not operating like market supply anymore. He's operating as a monopolist and as a result, too little is going to be consumed. People are going to buy less. There's going to be an under allocation of the resources, which is why monopoly can also result in market failure. For that one, you're going to have to go watch our video on monopoly in the theory of the firm first and then you can circle back and we'll look at how does monopoly cause there to be market failure.
Okay, so this has been introduction to market failure. We'll dive into each one of these examples in much more detail in subsequent videos. Let's do a quick recap. Market failure occurs when the free market, for some reason, fails to allocate resources efficiently. The quantity that the free market produces doesn't result in marginal cost equaling marginal benefit. We don't achieve allocative efficiency and there's a loss of social surplus. Positive externalities occur when someone external to the transaction, not the buyer, not the seller, someone else is somehow positively impacted by the fact that the good is being made and sold or bought and consumed. This results very often in too little of the good being produced in the market. Negative externalities occur when somebody external to the transaction is somehow negatively impacted by the transaction. Think back to Seth's party, right? Negative externalities very often will result in too much of that good or service being produced. Public goods are goods that are non-rival. When someone uses them, it doesn't mean someone else can't, and they're not excludable. You can't stop people from using them. Because you can't stop people from using them, too little is going to be produced by the free market.
Common access resources are resources that are non-excludable. You can't stop people from using them, but they are rival. At some point, they'll run out if people use it all up. Common access resources suffer from the tragedy of the commons, and too much of them is going to be consumed. Finally, monopoly is when there's only one firm in the market, and monopolists are going to charge a price that is higher than the free market, resulting in too little being produced and a failure to achieve allocative efficiency. Okay, in this unit, we're going to have one video for each one of these examples of market failure. Our next video is negative externalities of consumption.