5.2Negative Externalities of Consumption

19:21 October 1, 2026 6-question practice quiz

About this video

You know that person on the airplane who decides it's the perfect time to eat a tuna sandwich? Congratulations, you've experienced a negative externality of consumption. When people consume certain goods, the costs don't stop with them. They spill over onto everyone else nearby. In this video, we dig into demerit goods and how their consumption creates negative externalities. We'll use diagrams to show how the marginal private benefit and marginal social benefit curves split apart, why that leads to overconsumption and market failure, how it shows up as a welfare loss, and what governments can do about it, from taxes to bans to awareness campaigns. Please keep your tuna sandwiches stowed until the video is over.
Read the transcript

Okay, so we started to look at the concept of externalities in a previous video which introduced the idea of market failure in general. Negative externalities are external costs which must be borne by someone other than the producer or consumer of a good when that good is either produced or consumed. Today, we're going to be looking at negative externalities of consumption when that negative external cost arises as a result of the consumption of that good. I'm Mr. Racine. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.

To illustrate the concept of negative externalities of consumption, let's consider the market for cigarettes. Here we have an upward sloping supply curve for the supply of cigarettes. Let's assume that it costs our tobacco farmer $4 per pack of cigarettes to produce the first thousand packs of cigarettes. If he wants to make enough tobacco for the second thousand pack of cigarettes, let's say he needs to invest some more in fertilizer and machinery, so that second thousand packs of cigarettes has a higher additional cost than the first. Hence, the second thousand packs of cigarettes cost $5 to make or has a marginal cost of $5. If he wants to make enough tobacco to make the next thousand pack of cigarettes for a total of 3,000 packs of cigarettes, he'll have to like rent out some additional land and hire some workers, and that will cost him even more. So it costs him an additional $6 to produce that next thousand packs of cigarettes, bringing the total quantity to 3,000. And we have our upward sloping supply curve, which we know is also the same as the farmer's marginal cost curve. And we have our downward sloping demand curve, which coincides with consumers' marginal benefit curve. Let's say that there is a thousand Joe Hallenbecks and John McClanes, and they all like really value smoking. Each one of them has like an additional benefit of smoking one pack of cigarettes of like $8, right? So, the marginal benefit to those guys is $8.

So, if the price of cigarettes is $8, all of those guys will buy a pack of cigarettes, 1,000 packs of cigarettes will be sold. Let's say we also have 1,000 Don Drapers. They also like to smoke cuz it looks cool in the advertising agency, right? They value each pack of cigarettes at $7. So, the marginal benefit to those guys is $7. If the price of cigarettes is $7, then definitely the John McClanes and the Joe Hallenbecks are going to buy a pack at that price cuz they value it at eight. And the Don Drapers also, so quantity demanded is 2,000. And finally, we have our Bogies. And each one of them has a marginal benefit of smoking, let's say $6 per pack. They like it, but not as much as the other guys. So, if the price is $6, then we'll have a total quantity demanded of cigarettes of 3,000 packs of cigarettes. And we see we have our downward sloping demand curve, which is the same as our kind of marginal benefit curve in this market. Okay, and in the free market, we see that the market price is going to be $6. Quantity demanded of cigarettes is going to be 3,000 packs. Quantity supplied is going to be 3,000 packs. And we are in equilibrium. And if we want to like analyze social surplus and allocative efficiency, well, what we've been doing is we've been saying, well, supply is the same as the farmer's marginal cost, right? And demand is the same as the consumers' marginal benefit. So, at the quantity that the free market is producing and consuming 3,000 packs of cigarettes, marginal benefit is $6. The additional benefit to the last Bogie who smokes a pack of cigarettes is like $6 of happiness. Marginal cost is $6. The additional cost to the farmer to like rent that additional land and hire the worker to produce that 3,000th pack of cigarettes was $6.

We are at what we were calling the allocatively efficient quantity of output. But, what if there were some negative consequence borne by someone who's not the smokers and not the producers of the cigarettes external to the market mechanism itself? This is what we call a negative externality. We can consider it like the additional negative consequence to society as a result of Bogie smoking one more pack of cigarettes, and we're going to call that a negative externality of consumption. Negative externalities of consumption are the additional cost or additional burden which must be borne by someone external to the market, not the supplier or the consumer of the good themselves.

So, when someone smokes a cigarette, like clearly like immediate negative impact is to the people in their general area who like must be subjected to the secondhand smoke. So, that's like kind of a negative externality. But, a much bigger negative externality of smoking are like kind of the health care costs that are associated with smoking. We know that more smoking is associated with higher rates of lung disease and heart disease in a society. So, when there's a greater rate of smoking, there's a greater need for health care resources to both like treat those conditions, the increased lung disease, heart disease, and other health-related issues that arise from smoking, as well as to like try and research how to like cure those diseases. And it's not problematic to cure diseases, but we know that according to economics, resources are scarce. We have a fixed amount of land, labor, and capital that we have to dedicate to like the health care industry. And the use of those resources does have an opportunity cost. If you have a society where a large portion of health care costs are going towards treating smoking-related diseases which could have gone towards other diseases, then clearly that smoking has a burden on society greater than to those who are just smoking themselves.

Okay. So, goods like cigarettes are going to be goods that we call demerit goods. Goods that when they're consumed, they also have like a negative impact on society. And we could throw a host of other things in there, alcohol, cigarettes, probably gambling, things that have an addictive nature that can lead to negative societal impacts. And the things that they all have in common is that when they're consumed, they can lead to negative costs or burdens to people other than the parties who are producing and consuming them. So, in our diagram, every time that Joe Hallenbeck, or John McClane, or Don Draper, or, you know, Bogie decide to smoke a cigarette, they're going to be determining whether or not to smoke based upon the price of the cigarette and their own marginal benefit. The marginal benefit of that 3,000th pack of cigarettes consumed by this Bogie was we're saying according to the diagram $6. But that marginal benefit, now we're going to call the marginal private benefit. It's the benefit to Bogie that he gets the happiness and kind of sick feeling he gets from like smoking a pack of cigarettes and looking cool in black and white, right? But let's assume that for every pack of cigarettes that's smoked, this leads to an additional $1 cost to the health care industry where indirectly down the line every time somebody smokes a pack of cigarettes, it leads to somebody getting a disease which will increase health care costs by (we're just making up this number) let's say $1.

So, in fact, the benefit to society of Bogie smoking that last pack of cigarettes is the benefit that he gets, $6, minus the cost that we are assuming of $1. So, like the additional like total benefit of that 3,000th pack of cigarettes, if we're like thinking about it from a societal standpoint, is not $6, it's $5. We have to subtract out the additional cost to society. Similarly, when like this Don Draper smoked the 2,000th pack of cigarettes, it brought him like $7 worth of happiness or benefits. That's why he would have been willing to pay but we know that the actual additional benefit to society has to take into consideration that by smoking that pack, he's increasing costs to society of an additional dollar. So, actually society's only benefiting by a dollar less, like so $6. And Joe Hallenbeck and John McClane, you know, they love the cigarette. That thousandth pack of cigarettes was worth $8 to them, but we have to subtract out the cost. So, from a societal standpoint, the additional benefit was only $7. Connect the dots here and this is what we're going to call the marginal social benefit, the additional benefit from a societal standpoint from each additional pack of cigarettes. And this considers the private benefit, the additional benefit to the guy who's actually smoking the pack of cigarettes, but it also takes into consideration the additional cost to society that is generated as a result of the consumption of that pack of cigarettes.

So, I'm going to say that there isn't really any harm to society when tobacco is grown. Like, I don't think it really negatively impacts the environment, and no one's actually smoking it when you grow it. So, I'm going to say that the supply curve, which is the farmer's marginal private cost curve, is also going to be the marginal social cost curve because there's not really any harm being done in the actual supply of the cigarettes. It's when it's consumed that the harm is being done. So, based upon that we have our supply curve, which is the farmer's marginal private cost curve, which is also what we're going to call our marginal social cost curve. We have our demand curve, which is we know the marginal private benefit curve for Bogie and all of the other guys who smoke. And then we have the marginal social benefit curve, which falls below the marginal private benefit curve because of this additional cost to society that is incurred each time somebody lights up and smokes a pack of cigarettes. Okay, so at the equilibrium quantity, the quantity that the free market is going to produce where supply equals demand, we now see that this is marginal social benefit and this is marginal social cost.

Marginal social cost is greater than marginal social benefit. From a societal standpoint, we are not achieving allocative efficiency. That 3,000th pack of cigarettes that gets smoked by Bogie has an additional cost to society which is greater than the additional benefit to society. Too much is being produced. We're not achieving allocative efficiency. This is why negative externalities of consumption lead to market failure, to the free market producing at the quantity where marginal social benefit does not equal marginal social cost. In this case, the additional cost is greater than the additional benefit, too much is being produced and consumed. So, clearly the socially optimal quantity would be this quantity right here where marginal social cost equals marginal social benefit. So, we're going to call that the socially optimal quantity of output, where we would like the market to be producing.

Why does the free market produce here, at this quantity, right, the equilibrium quantity, and not at the socially optimal quantity? Well, it has to do with the fact that like smokers, they don't care about what the marginal social benefit is when they're deciding whether or not to smoke a pack of cigarettes. They're considering what is the additional benefit to me and what is the price that I need to pay in order to like engage in this activity or consume this thing. And as long as the additional benefit exceeds the additional cost for the smoker, they're going to do it. Similarly, producers are going to make decisions according to private costs. So, the free market is always going to produce where supply equals demand, right? We spent like a whole bunch of videos like going over the free market and supply and demand. The free market doesn't take into consideration these external costs. And so, we're going to arrive here at this quantity, which in this case is too much, and we would like the free market to be producing here, where marginal social benefit equals marginal social cost.

We can also consider the impact on social surplus. Okay, so at the free market quantity that is being produced is quantity here and this price here. This is consumer surplus. This is producer surplus, so kind of our usual suspects right here. Now, we have to add in the negative cost to society, which arises as a result of people smoking and consuming the cigarette. So, the additional cost is like the vertical distance here between the marginal private benefit and the marginal social benefit, right? That's the cost. That's why it shifted down. And we can just like multiply it times the quantity to get the total like cost to society of this quantity of cigarettes being smoked. So, the total cost to society of Q star cigarettes being smoked is this area right here. So, we can see that this part of this cost is also like gained in consumer surplus, so they kind of cancel each other out and it becomes nothing in terms of social surplus. This little part right here is gained back in producer surplus, so that cost and surplus cancel each other out, so they disappear. And so, what we're left with is this area here as the surplus which isn't canceled out by the negative cost, and then this additional cost area right here. So, social surplus at the free market quantity is kind of this area minus this area right here.

So what about at the socially optimal quantity and socially optimal price? Well, this area right here is going to be producer surplus, right? The area above supply and below the price. And this kind of area right here would be consumer surplus, right? The area below demand, above price, and we're kind of capped off by the quantity that's actually being consumed. And then, this is the cost right here again, right? This vertical distance between marginal social benefit and marginal private benefit times the quantity that's consumed. So this area right here kind of cancels out with the consumer surplus. And so, when we produce at the socially optimal level of output, this is kind of social surplus. So, at the socially optimal level of output, this is social surplus. At market output, this minus this is social surplus.

So, at the free market level of output, we have an additional cost that's not there when we produce at the socially optimal level of output. And that's this thing right here. We're going to call that thing the deadweight loss or the loss of social surplus. Again, evidence that the free market is not producing at the allocatively efficient quantity. When we achieve allocative efficiency, social surplus is maximized. Well, we're clearly not maximizing social surplus when social surplus is this minus this at the free market outcome, and it's this at the socially optimal level of output. Okay, so negative externalities of consumption cause a free market to produce too much. Marginal social cost exceeds marginal social benefit and there's deadweight loss or a loss of social surplus. Okay, so the free market is going to produce here and the socially optimal level of output is here. So what steps could the government take to like reduce consumption of smoking? Let's look at three kinds of solutions: education and advertising, legislation, and taxes.

Okay, the government can take steps to promote the negative health impacts of smoking cigarettes and you know, they've done this a ton with all of the anti-smoking campaigns that are out there. This serves, then, to in theory reduce individual consumers' perceived marginal benefit of smoking, right? Like what's the additional benefit of you smoking another pack of cigarettes? Like if it increases the chance that I'm going to die sooner, right? Probably it's going to be a different additional perceived cost for each individual because everyone has their own kind of risk profile and attachment to smoking cigarettes, but in theory you'd expect it to reduce the additional benefit for everyone in some capacity. If like you are aware that like smoking could cause you to get a disease that could end your life early. This serves then to reduce demand for cigarettes hopefully in theory until demand is reduced to a point where we get to the socially optimal level of cigarette smoking. Okay, legislation. The government can also make it like more difficult to smoke. They can restrict the age groups who can smoke. They can make it not legal to smoke in certain public spaces. In Britain, anyone born after 2009 will never be old enough to buy tobacco products ever again according to a law that is currently on the books. Crazy, huh? All of this serves to like reduce the amount of people who are able to buy cigarettes or who are buying cigarettes, thereby reducing demand and again in theory decreasing the quantity consumed until we get to the socially optimal quantity of output.

The final solution is the economist's solution: a specific tax on suppliers. We remember from our previous video on taxes that taxes decrease supply shifting the supply curve to the left. And we actually said that taxes are one of the only times when we talk about shifting the supply curve upwards. And we said that the effect was that a specific tax on suppliers would shift the supply curve up by the amount of the tax per unit. So the government can opt to impose a specific tax on cigarette manufacturers.

If they could in theory estimate this negative external cost to society that is borne with each pack of cigarettes that is smoked, they could then impose a tax of the same exact size which would then shift the supply curve upwards until we have our supply plus tax curve. Okay, now this is our supply plus tax curve. This is our private demand curve. Where those two intersect is where the market is now going to produce. At this quantity, the socially optimal quantity, and at this higher price for consumers. Producers don't get to keep all of it, right? Producers have to pay the tax. So they actually receive this lower price down here. Okay, so in theory it works really well and we like this solution as economists. And one of the reasons is because it takes what was once an external cost, a cost that society had to bear, that wasn't directly borne by the smokers or the cigarette manufacturers, and makes it an internal cost by creating a tax that must be paid every time the pack of cigarettes is purchased in the market. Part of this cost is borne by the smokers of the cigarettes as evidenced by the increase in price that they pay compared to the original market price, and part of this is also borne by the producers, the manufacturers of cigarettes, as evidenced by the lower price that they receive after paying the tax to the government.

This additional cost then gives both producers and consumers incentive to reduce production and consumption of cigarettes until in theory we can get to the socially optimal quantity of output and achieve allocative efficiency. Okay, so we can do a quick review of negative externalities of consumption. Market failure occurs when the free market fails to produce at the quantity when marginal benefit equals marginal cost. Introducing the concept of externalities, we're now going to expand that definition to say it occurs where marginal social benefit does not equal marginal social cost. A negative externality of consumption arises when the consumption of a good results in some negative external cost or burden that is borne by someone other than the consumer or producer of the good. This then means that the marginal social benefit of consuming a good that generates negative externalities of consumption must fall below the marginal private benefit to reflect the additional cost to society.

Because consumers make decisions according to marginal private benefit and not marginal social benefit, too much of the good is going to be consumed and at the quantity that the free market produces and consumes, marginal social cost is going to exceed marginal social benefit. We do not achieve allocative efficiency. So, when we have negative externalities of consumption, it leads to market failure. Solutions to negative externalities of consumption to reduce consumption to the socially optimal level include education to try and get people to realize the negative impacts and reduce consumption on their own, legislation to make it more difficult for consumption of the good or service, and taxation, which internalizes the external cost giving producers and consumers incentive to reduce the production and consumption of the good. Okay, next class, we're going to take a look at the flip side: positive externalities of consumption. Why does everything have to be so negative? See you there.

UNIT 5 More in Market Failure