2.6bMarginal Cost and Supply
13:57 November 7, 2023 6-question practice quiz
In this video
About this video
Read the transcript
It's weird and counterintuitive that supply is upward sloping. It seems to me that businesses want to produce and sell as much as possible, and the idea that businesses are only going to be willing to make and sell more of a good at a higher price is ludicrous. We've made a partial explanation of the logic behind an upward-sloping supply curve in a previous video, but it was neither complete nor satisfying. In this video, we'll try to better explain the upward-sloping supply curve using the concept of marginal cost. I'm Mr. Racine. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.
To introduce the concept of marginal cost, let's use as an example a simple business: a hot dog cart owned by this guy, the Hot Dog Baron. The inputs for this business are the hot dog cart, which keeps the dogs warm and transports them; the ingredients for the hot dogs (the meat, the buns, the condiments); and labor, which is required to make and sell the hot dogs. Let's say that the Hot Dog Baron has three basic costs associated with operating the hot dog cart. The rental cost of the cart and the fee that the owner needs to pay to the city in order to get the license to operate on the street are fixed, and the owner needs to pay this amount regardless of the total amount of hot dogs that he produces and sells. In a later video, we'll refer to these as fixed costs. We also have the cost of ingredients for the hot dogs themselves; let's say each hot dog costs the owner $1, all in: bun, meat, ingredients. And finally, we have the cost of labor, the worker who actually assembles and sells the hot dogs, and let's say that labor costs $10 a day.
Okay, let's say that the Hot Dog Baron hires one worker, and in one day, that one worker can sell 10 hot dogs. Okay, if the Hot Dog Baron decides that he wants to produce and sell more hot dogs, it's not going to be possible to rent another cart tomorrow; they're rented on a monthly basis. So the only thing that he can do is hire more labor. But these new workers have to take the hot dogs from the cart and walk a little bit further away to try and sell the hot dogs. As a result, they're less efficient than the first guy, who gets to stand right by the cart and just hand the hot dogs out. So if the Hot Dog Baron wants to increase his production and sales of hot dogs to 20, he needs to hire two more workers, for a total of three workers. The first guy stays at the cart and sells 10 hot dogs, and the next two guys walk a little bit further away, and they're each capable of selling five hot dogs in a day. If the Hot Dog Baron wants to sell even more, he needs to hire even more workers, and these guys need to travel even further from the cart in search of customers. So let's say if he wants to sell 30 hot dogs, he needs to hire, in total, six workers. And finally, if he wants to sell 40 hot dogs, he needs to hire workers that are going to schlep even further away, so in order to sell 40 hot dogs, he needs to employ a total of 10 workers.
Okay, so this is the setup. Let's use it to better understand how increasing the amount of hot dogs that are being produced and sold affects the costs of the business. In order to do that, we need to introduce the idea of marginal cost. Marginal cost is defined as the additional cost of producing and selling one more unit of a good or service. It's calculated as the change in total cost divided by the change in total output. In the case of the hot dog vendor, marginal cost would be: how much more money does the hot dog vendor have to pay to produce one more hot dog?
So if the Hot Dog Baron decides to shut down for the day and produce and sell zero hot dogs, he still needs to pay the cost of rental for the cart, as well as the licensing fee to the city. These are fixed costs that don't change with the level of production. These costs don't change when the vendor decides to produce more or less, so they're actually not related to marginal cost, which is only considering the additional costs incurred when deciding to produce more.
Okay, so in order to produce and sell 10 hot dogs, the hot dog vendor has to buy the ingredients for 10 hot dogs, and he has to hire one worker. That worker costs $10, and we know that the ingredients cost $1 per dog, for a total of $10 for ingredients. So those first 10 hot dogs that are produced increase cost by a total of $20. Using our equation for the calculation of marginal cost: if we increase output from zero hot dogs to 10 hot dogs, we produced 10 more hot dogs, and our costs increased by a total of $20. $20 divided by 10 hot dogs is $2 per dog. The marginal cost of the first hot dog is $2, as well as the second, the third, the fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh, eighth, ninth, tenth hot dog. The Baron needs to pay an additional $2 to produce each one of those first 10 hot dogs.
Okay, so if the Hot Dog Baron decides that he wants to produce and sell more hot dogs, he needs to hire more labor. Specifically, if he wants to increase production to 20, in our model, he needs to hire two more workers. In order to increase output from 10 hot dogs to 20 hot dogs, an increase in total product, or total quantity, of 10, the Hot Dog Baron needs to hire two more workers, for a cost of $20, and pay for $10 more worth of raw ingredients, for a total increase in cost of $30. The marginal cost of the 11th hot dog, 12th hot dog, 13, 14, 15... 20th hot dog, each, is $3. Each one of those hot dogs cost the vendor an additional $3 to make. To increase production from 20 hot dogs to 30 hot dogs, the vendor now needs to hire three more workers. This increases total cost by $30 for the workers, plus $10 for the ingredients, for a total of $40. The marginal cost of the 21st, 22nd, 23rd... 30th hot dog is $4 each. And finally, to increase production to 40 hot dogs, he needs to hire four more workers and pay for 10 more hot dogs' worth of ingredients, which increases total cost by $50. So the marginal cost of these next 10 hot dogs is $5.
We can plot the marginal cost curve on a diagram. We put marginal cost on the vertical axis and quantity of hot dogs on the horizontal axis. The first 10 hot dogs increase cost by $2 each, so the marginal cost of each of those first 10 hot dogs is $2. The next 10 hot dogs, hot dogs 10 to 20, increase cost by $3 a piece, so the marginal cost of those next 10 hot dogs is $3. The marginal cost of hot dogs 21 to 30 is $4, and the marginal cost of hot dogs 31 to 40 is $5.
So we can use this marginal cost curve to then think about: how do changes to price affect the Hot Dog Baron's willingness to make and sell hot dogs? In a previous video, we came up with various explanations of why the Hot Dog Baron himself is not setting the price, all of them equally unsatisfying, but we're going to continue that assumption in this model. Here, the price is coming from outside the Hot Dog Baron's decision-making process. Let's say that we live in a command economy, and that the city determines the price of hot dogs that the vendor is allowed to sell at. If they say that the hot dog vendor can sell hot dogs for $1, is he going to be willing to produce and sell any hot dogs at all? Well, it costs him $2 each to make these first 10 hot dogs; that's what this marginal cost curve is telling us. The additional cost of the first hot dog is $2. It doesn't make any sense for him to pay $2 to make something that he can only sell for $1. He's guaranteed to lose money.
So how much money does the hot dog vendor need to be able to sell his hot dogs for in order to be willing to produce and sell these first 10 hot dogs? Well, at least $2, because this is the additional cost of producing each one of those first 10 hot dogs. The hot dog vendor will sell these first 10 hot dogs as long as he gets at least $2 for them in return. But will he sell the next 10 hot dogs at a price of $2, that is, hot dog number 11, 12, 13, 14, 15... 19, 20? Well, we know from our analysis that the marginal cost, the additional cost, of producing hot dog number 11, 12, 13, 14, et cetera, is $3. Again, it makes no sense to pay $3 for something that you can only sell for $2.
Okay, but what if, on the second day, the city decides that they're going to increase the price, and now the hot dog vendor can sell his hot dogs for $3? Is he going to be willing to produce and sell these first 10 hot dogs? Absolutely. Those first 10 hot dogs only increase cost by $2 a piece; they have a marginal cost of $2, and you're definitely going to pay $2 to make something that you can sell for $3. You'd be crazy not to. How about the next 10 hot dogs? Well, they have a marginal cost of $3. As long as the hot dog vendor gets $3 or more, then he's going to be willing to produce and sell those hot dogs as well. So at a price of $3, we assume that the hot dog vendor is going to produce and sell 20 hot dogs. He's only going to become willing to produce the next 10 hot dogs, hot dogs 21 through 30, if he's guaranteed to get a price of at least $4, because that's his marginal cost of producing those hot dogs; that's how much more he has to pay to make them. And finally, if price goes up to $5 or more, that's when he becomes willing to make up to 40 hot dogs.
So this marginal cost curve here is somehow also telling us the total quantity of hot dogs that the Hot Dog Baron is willing to produce and sell at different prices, which is just the supply curve. The supply curve is a marginal cost curve! Holy Tuesday! When we say it's a marginal cost curve, we read it like this: when the vendor produces 10 hot dogs, the marginal cost of those first 10 hot dogs was $2 a piece. When the hot dog vendor produces 20 hot dogs, the additional cost of hot dog number 11, 12... 20 was $3. When we say it's a supply curve, we read it like this: if the price is $2, the hot dog vendor would be willing to produce and sell 10 hot dogs. If the price is $3, the hot dog vendor is willing to produce and sell 20 hot dogs. But again, those two concepts are inextricably intertwined. Why does the hot dog vendor need to get at least $3 in order to be willing to increase production of hot dogs from 10 to 20? Because the marginal cost of hot dogs 11, 12, 13, 14... 19, 20 is $3. We're going to come back to this idea a lot more extensively when we get to the theory of the firm and short-run production and costs, but for now: the supply curve is a marginal cost curve. It's a super, super important idea.
Okay, so this has been my attempt to convince you that the supply curve is a marginal cost curve. I realize that we've still made some weird assumptions (the guy has to walk really far to sell more hot dogs), but believe me, we can make similar assumptions for almost all industries that will make sense. But for now: supply is marginal cost. Marginal cost is the additional cost of producing one more unit of output. It can be calculated as the change in total cost divided by the change in total product, or total quantity. Using some simple, not-too-egregious assumptions, we can show that marginal cost increases as output increases, at least in the short run (and we'll come back to what that means later). As a result, the marginal cost curve is the supply curve. It shows us the price that a producer needs to receive in order to increase his output, which is simply equal to the additional cost of producing that additional output.
Okay, next video, we're going to introduce some really important concepts: consumer surplus, producer surplus, and allocative efficiency. See you there.
UNIT 2 More in Supply and Demand
19:01
2.1 Demand Introduced
16:05
2.1a Non-Price Determinants of Demand
13:01
2.2 Supply Introduced
12:18
2.2a Non-Price Determinants of Supply
7:17
2.3 Supply and Demand in Equilibrium
10:38
2.4 Shifts to Supply and Demand
12:17
2.5 Simultaneous Shifts to Supply and Demand
18:26
2.6a Marginal Utility, Marginal Benefit, and Demand
13:57
NOW PLAYING
2.6b Marginal Cost and Supply
11:31
2.7 Consumer Surplus, Producer Surplus, and Social Surplus
8:45
2.8 Allocative Efficiency