4.2Subsidies

18:12 February 17, 2025 6-question practice quiz

About this video

Ever wonder why the U.S. grows so much corn? It’s not just because we love popcorn—it's because subsidies help make it happen. The government, in its infinite wisdom (or at least its strong opinions), steps in to support farmers, ensuring that fields stay planted, prices stay stable, and ethanol keeps flowing into gas tanks. Sure, maybe we don’t all need quite this much corn, but hey, when Washington says, “Grow it, and we’ll pay,” who’s turning that down? But subsidies aren’t just about corn—they shape industries, influence prices, and keep certain businesses afloat when markets get rough. Some call it economic stability, others call it market interference. Either way, when it comes to government incentives, one thing’s for sure: if there’s money on the table, someone’s going to build something to take it.
Read the transcript

I'm Mr. Racine. Today, we're going to take a look at the impact of subsidies on markets. Let's get to it. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.

This is Ray, a corn farmer. At the beginning of every planting season, Ray needs to decide how much corn he wants to plant. Now, the price of corn can be quite volatile; it can go up or down quite a lot over the course of a planting season, which can make it quite difficult for Ray to decide how much corn to plant. Luckily for Ray, there are these financial instruments called corn futures, which Ray can use to lock in a guaranteed future price for his corn, so he doesn't have to worry about the price of corn falling through the floor after he's planted it.

If, at the beginning of the planting season, Ray can secure a corn futures price of $6 per bushel, meaning he can sell his corn at that price three months from now, it's not even going to be worth his time. The cost of land, labor, and capital is just too high, and planting corn isn't going to be profitable. Ray will supply zero bushels of corn to the market, and he'll use his land for some other purpose. If you build it, he will come. Okay, however, if the price of corn now goes up to $9 per bushel, then it is worth it for Ray to actually use some of his land to plant corn. In that case, he'll abandon Shoeless Joe and the gang and decide to actually plant corn, and he'll plant, let's say, 1,000 bushels of corn for the season. If Ray can get a corn future at $12, it'll be worth it for him to hire some additional help. He'll plant even more corn, and he'll supply 2,000 bushels of corn to the market. And at a higher price of $15, he can even afford to rent that fancy tractor, and he'll grow 3,000 bushels of corn. So here we have Ray's supply curve, which shows the different quantities of corn that he'll grow at different prices.

Now, let's say that the corn lobby, a group of people who represent corn farmers, goes down to Washington, and they convince the good people of Washington that corn farmers are underpaid and need additional help from the government. Washington agrees, and they decide to implement a specific, or per-unit, subsidy in the corn market, which is a specific dollar amount that will be given to corn farmers based upon the quantity of corn that they grow and sell. If corn farmers grow more, they will get a larger subsidy. In our example, let's say that the government agrees to pay corn farmers an additional $3 per bushel of corn that they grow and sell.

So let's take a look at how we would expect this to impact Ray's supply curve. Previously, if corn futures were locked in at $6, we said that wasn't going to be worth Ray's time; he's going to build a baseball field instead, right? But now, with a subsidy in place, if the market price is $6, Ray realizes that he can sell his corn and get $6 from the buyer, but then also get another $3 on top of that from the government, meaning in reality, Ray would be receiving $9 per bushel of corn sold. And we know that at a price of $9 per bushel, from Ray's perspective, it's worth it for him to actually grow some corn: 1,000 bushels of corn, in fact. So this means that at a market price of $6, plus the $3 from the government, Ray will now grow 1,000 bushels of corn.

Previously, at a hypothetical corn futures price of $9, Ray was going to be willing to produce and sell 1,000 bushels of corn. But now he realizes that if the market price were $9, he would also get $3 from the government, meaning in total, Ray is receiving $12 per bushel. And at a price of $12 per bushel, Ray is going to be willing to produce and sell 2,000 bushels of corn. So if the market price is $9, Ray gets another three from the government, and he's going to produce and sell 2,000 bushels of corn. Similarly, at a market price of $12, Ray actually gets $15 after the subsidy, which encourages him to grow 3,000 bushels when the market price is $12.

So this thing is Ray's supply curve with the subsidy. Very often, we'll label it "supply minus the subsidy." It tells us that if this is the market price, this is the quantity that Ray would be willing to produce and sell; if this is the market price, this is the quantity that Ray would be willing to produce and sell, with the subsidy in place. And notice that the supply curve with the subsidy is just Ray's original supply curve shifted downwards by the amount of the subsidy per unit. With no subsidy in place, Ray needs to get $9 in order to be willing to grow any corn. But now the government says they're going to give him $3 for every bushel that he grows, so he actually only needs to get $6 from the consumer in order to be willing to produce and sell. He's willing to produce that same quantity, but now for $3 less, and this is true at every price-quantity combination. The supply curve is shifted downwards by the amount of the subsidy per unit.

When we looked at non-price determinants of supply, one of the things that we said could increase supply in a market was subsidies to that particular market, and we said that would shift the supply curve outwards, as that's how we represent an increase in supply. However, in this case, it may be more useful to consider this as a downward shift of the supply curve, as the supply curve actually shifts down by the amount of the subsidy per unit.

Which brings us to today's happy premise number one: a subsidy to suppliers will shift the supply curve downwards by the amount of the subsidy per unit. If this is the supply curve for electric cars in Arizona, and the government implements a $4,000 subsidy per car sold, the supply curve shifts down by $4,000. If this is the supply curve for health insurance in France, and the government provides a $500-a-month subsidy, it shifts the supply curve downwards by $500.

Okay, now here we have the market supply curve and the market demand curve for corn in Iowa. This supply curve now represents the sum of all of the individual farmer supply curves, like Ray's. We can see that in this market, the equilibrium price is $9 per bushel, and the equilibrium quantity is 60,000 bushels of corn. Now let's assume that the government implements a $3-per-bushel subsidy for suppliers of corn, which shifts the market supply curve downwards by $3. At our original equilibrium price of $9, there's now a surplus in the market. Buyers still only want to buy 60,000 bushels of corn, but suppliers are now willing to produce and sell 120,000 bushels of corn. This surplus puts downward pressure on prices. This downward pressure on price causes quantity demanded to increase and quantity supplied to fall until they're equal again, and we arrive at a new equilibrium price of $7 and a new equilibrium quantity of 80,000 bushels of corn. So what has happened? We've implemented the subsidy. It shifts the supply curve downwards, or outwards, and as expected, it causes prices to fall and equilibrium quantity to rise.

Happy premise number two: the implementation of a subsidy to suppliers will cause the equilibrium price in the market to fall and equilibrium quantity to increase.

Okay, so let's take a look at how this subsidy impacts different stakeholders in the market, namely producers, consumers, and the government. From the perspective of consumers, it appears like they're better off. Price falls from $9 to $7; that's good. And quantity consumed increases from 60,000 to 80,000; that's also probably good. Consumers pay a lower price, and they buy more. Consumer expenditure increases from $540,000 ($9 times 60,000, this area here) to $560,000 ($7 times 80,000, this area here). Technically, consumer expenditure could go up or down; it does depend upon whether demand is price elastic or inelastic. But the most important thing is that consumers get to buy more corn, and at a lower price.

What about suppliers? Well, suppliers also seem to be better off. The quantity that they sell increases from 60,000 to 80,000, and that's good. Additionally, we need to consider how much money producers are receiving for every bushel of corn that they sell. Well, consumers are paying $7, right? That's the market equilibrium price for consumers. But we have to remember that producers are also receiving the additional $3 subsidy from the government on top of what the consumers are paying them. So this means, then, that producers are actually receiving a total of $10 per bushel of corn that they sell, and that's good also. The price received by producers increases from $9 to $10. Total producer revenue, then, increases from $540,000 ($9 times 60,000, this area here) to $800,000 ($10 times 80,000, this area here). Suppliers also win: they get a higher price, and they sell more corn.

So it's amazing! We've just discovered this thing that creates free benefits for everyone. Consumers pay lower prices, producers receive higher prices, everyone sells and buys more. Let's just subsidize everything! But what am I ignoring? What's the cost? Right, it's not free. The government has to pay for the subsidy. The subsidy per unit is $3 per bushel, and they need to subsidize a total of 80,000 bushels sold. The total cost to government, then, is represented by this area here: $3 times 80,000, or $240,000, to finance this subsidy.

Which brings us to happy premise number three: a specific, or per-unit, subsidy granted to suppliers will enable consumers to buy more and at a lower price, and will enable producers to sell more and receive a higher price. But there's a cost to government.

We could also consider how all of this affects consumer and producer surplus, as well as social surplus. Before the implementation of the subsidy, consumer surplus is represented by this triangle here, the area above the market price and below the demand curve, and we would calculate it as one half times $6 times 60,000, for a total of $180,000. After the implementation of the subsidy, consumers now pay this lower price of $7 and consume a higher quantity of 80,000, so consumer surplus increases to this bigger triangle here. After the implementation of the subsidy, consumer surplus is calculated as one half times $8 times 80,000, for a total of $320,000. Consumer surplus increases by $140,000, the area of which is represented right here.

Producer surplus increases as well. Prior to the subsidy, producer surplus is this triangle here, the area below price and above the supply curve. This is equal to one half times 3 times 60,000, for a total of $90,000 of producer surplus. After implementing the subsidy, producers sell more, and they also now receive this higher price of $10, right? Remember, consumers pay $7, but producers also get the $3 from the government, so in essence, producers are receiving $10 for every unit that they sell. So producer surplus is going to be represented by the triangle above their supply curve, but now below the price that they receive, which is this $10 here. So producer surplus is now this bigger triangle here, which is calculated as one half times 4 times 80,000, for a total of $160,000. Producer surplus increases by $70,000, and that increase in producer surplus is represented by this area here.

Okay, so this is producer surplus with no subsidy, this is producer surplus with the subsidy, and this is the gain in producer surplus. This is consumer surplus with no subsidy, this is consumer surplus with the subsidy, and this is the gain in consumer surplus. Together, these two shapes represent the total increase in consumer and producer surplus brought on by the subsidy. But like we said before, this isn't free, right? The government has to finance this subsidy. And where is the cost of financing the subsidy? It's represented by this area here: $3 times 80,000 bushels, for a total cost of $240,000 to finance the subsidy. Notice that consumers gain $140,000 in surplus and producers gain $70,000 in surplus, which is a total gain of $210,000 in surplus. But it costs $240,000 to finance the subsidy, so the gain in surplus by producers and consumers is less than the cost to government of financing the subsidy. The government, in effect, is paying this much too much to finance the subsidy. This area right here is the government expenditure that is not somehow getting translated into either consumer or producer surplus.

This is consumer surplus; this is the consumer surplus gain. This is producer surplus; this is the producer surplus gain. So this area here is, like, the total surplus that is gained, but the government also, like, spends this area here in the form of government expenditure. So this portion of government expenditure pays for this increase in consumer surplus: the government pays and loses, and consumers gain, so, like, in effect, they cancel each other out. This is neither a gain nor a loss when you consider both of them together. And the same goes for producers: producers gain the surplus, and the government needs to pay for that area, so these two areas cancel each other out. So what are we left with? We're left with this little area here, which is government expenditure that, again, doesn't go to either consumer surplus or producer surplus. This area here represents the deadweight loss, or the loss of social surplus, that arises as a result of the implementation of the subsidy.

Happy premise number four: in the absence of externalities, the cost of financing a subsidy will exceed the gain in producer and consumer surplus resulting from that subsidy, thereby resulting in deadweight loss, or a loss of social surplus.

Finally, how does all of this affect allocative efficiency? When there's no subsidy, 60,000 bushels of corn are sold, and the market price is $9. We know that the supply curve is the same as the marginal cost curve, and the demand curve is the same as the marginal benefit curve. So when the market is in equilibrium with no subsidy, at a quantity of 60,000, marginal benefit is $9, and when producers produce and sell 60,000, marginal cost is $9. At market equilibrium with no subsidy, marginal benefit equals marginal cost. This is what we like to see. We like it when the additional cost to farmers of producing that last bushel of corn is equal to the additional benefit to consumers of consuming that last bushel of corn. What do we call this? Allocative efficiency, when marginal benefit equals marginal cost.

What about after the implementation of the subsidy? Now the market is going to produce 80,000 bushels of corn, and when we produce 80,000 bushels of corn, we know that marginal benefit is only $7, and marginal cost is actually $10. The marginal cost, the additional cost to producers of making that last unit of corn, is greater than the additional benefit to consumers of consuming that last unit of corn. Marginal cost exceeds marginal benefit: too much corn is being produced. There's an overallocation of resources; we do not achieve allocative efficiency, and in essence, there is now market failure.

Happy premise number five: in the absence of externalities, a subsidy will cause an overallocation of resources.

Okay, so today we talked about specific, or per-unit, subsidies to suppliers. Let's do a quick review. One: a specific, or per-unit, subsidy to suppliers will cause the supply curve to shift downwards by the dollar amount of the subsidy per unit. Two: this will result in a lower price paid by consumers and a greater quantity consumed in the market. Three: consumers will be made better off, because they consume more, and at a lower price; consumer surplus increases. Four: producers are also better off, because they sell more and they receive a higher price after factoring in the subsidy; producer surplus increases. Five: there is a cost to the government, and that is equal to the subsidy per unit times the total quantity sold in the market. Six: the total government expenditure to finance a subsidy will exceed the gain in producer and consumer surplus, causing there to be deadweight loss as a result of the subsidy, when there are no externalities. Seven: similarly, when there are no externalities, subsidies result in an overallocation of resources.

Okay, okay. Next time, we're going to take a look at what happens if the government decides that prices are too high in a market. We'll take a look at something called price ceilings. Come on, come check it out.

UNIT 4 More in Government Intervention