2.6aMarginal Utility, Marginal Benefit, and Demand

18:26 October 31, 2023 6-question practice quiz

About this video

Time to dive into something that’ll really make you rethink how you see the world. Ever heard of diminishing marginal utility? It’s basically when the more you consume of something, the less excited you get about it. Think of it like eating your 7th rubber chicken at a medieval-themed dinner theater. The first one was kinda fun—by the 7th, you’re just wondering why you’re still holding onto this oddly chewy thing. That’s diminishing returns in action. Now, marginal benefit is related to marginal utility, but instead of measuring satisfaction in “utils” (which sounds like a weird currency from a sci-fi movie), we measure it in dollars—what people are willing to pay for each additional unit of something. So, the more of something you consume, the less you’re willing to pay for it. In other words, your marginal benefit starts to drop as your marginal utility drops. Pretty simple, right? But here’s the kicker: the Demand Curve is the same thing as the Marginal Benefit Curve. Wait, what? Yeah, it’s true. The amount a consumer is willing to pay for a good or service is reflected in the demand curve, which shows the marginal benefit of each additional unit consumed. It’s not magic—it’s just how economics works. So, pay close attention, and maybe rewatch it if you need to (like this season of The Bachelor, which you totally claim you don’t watch, but somehow find yourself rewatching the entire season... just saying). Once it clicks, you’ll never look at demand the same way again.
Read the transcript

In a previous video, we introduced the concepts of the income effect and the substitution effect as the rationale for a downward-sloping demand curve and the law of demand. There's one more concept we can introduce to help us better understand why people buy more of a good at lower prices, or, conversely, why rising prices discourage the consumption of a good. These are the ideas of marginal utility and the closely related concept of marginal benefit. I'm Mr. Racine. Welcome to today's episode of Economics Videos That Don't Suck.

To introduce the concept of marginal utility, I need to introduce two very personal things about myself. The first is: I love Twinkies. These delightful golden packets of joy are manufactured by the Hostess company. They're rumored to be nuclear-bomb-proof, and were taken off the market for an agonizing period in 2012. I have my special Twinkie tie on for this video. Check it out. Okay, so yes, I love Twinkies. The second thing to know about me is that I am a rational thinker, according to economic theory. What this means is, when I'm deciding how many Twinkies I want to consume, I need to take into consideration how much satisfaction or happiness I'm getting from each Twinkie. This brings us to the concept of marginal utility.

In economics, utility is the satisfaction or happiness that we get from consuming a good or service. The concept of happiness or satisfaction is quite abstract, and it's unique to each consumer, but we can make some generalizations about the idea using this concept of utility. We measure utility in utils, an imaginary unit of measure that is designed to try and capture satisfaction or happiness. So, for example, if my utility of eating an apple is determined to be 10 utils, and my utility of eating an orange is determined to be eight utils, then we understand that the apple brings me more satisfaction than the orange. If I were forced to choose between the apple and the orange, I would choose the apple, because it brings me a higher degree of satisfaction.

But in economics, we like to think at the margin, so that brings us to the concept of marginal utility. Generally speaking, the margin means the edge. I got in trouble in English class in seventh grade for drawing inappropriate cartoons in the margin of my book. If somebody lives under a bridge and makes art out of body hair, we say they live on the margin of society. So the margin means the edge. In economics, whenever we talk about marginal anything (marginal cost, marginal benefit, marginal revenue, marginal product, marginal utility), the concept is looking at what happens when we do one more of something. In the case of marginal utility, we're concerned with: what is the additional utility, or additional satisfaction, that one gains from consuming one more unit of a good?

So we can conduct an experiment to try and measure Mr. Racine's marginal utility of eating Twinkies. I think, subconsciously, when the idea of this entire video series germinated, it was really just so that I could have the opportunity to make this video.

Okay, okay. First Twinkie, down the hatch. It's good. It's creamy. I haven't had a Twinkie in probably five years, because I'm an adult person. Yeah, that's... that's quite good. Let's say that that first Twinkie gave me 40 utils of satisfaction. It's really good.

Okay. Twinkie number two. Yeah, it's good. It's definitely not as good as the first one, because I was really hungry, but it's good. I definitely wouldn't say it made me as satisfied as the first Twinkie, because I was really hungry, but I liked it. Let's give it 30 utils.

Okay, let me pause really quickly here to point out that since we're using this imaginary unit of measure, the util, the magnitude, or the number of utils by itself, isn't really very important. It's only when we compare between two different goods that utils become meaningful. I could have just as easily said that the first Twinkie gave me four utils of satisfaction and the second Twinkie gave me three utils of satisfaction, and I'd be saying the same thing: the first Twinkie made me more satisfied; the second Twinkie increased my satisfaction, but only by 75% of the first. Okay, that was just actually a delay tactic to try and get my stomach to settle down from that second Twinkie.

Okay, so let's go for the third Twinkie. Twinkie number three. It's good. I like it. It's getting a little bit sweet, though. Okay, let's say 20 utils of satisfaction from the third Twinkie.

Okay, Twinkie number four. Let's go. Yeah, I like it. I'm getting a little bit sick of it. Okay, 10 utils of satisfaction.

Twinkie number five. I don't like it. It's not making me any happier. It's fine, I mean, I'll put it in my mouth and chew, but it's not adding to my happiness. Zero utils of satisfaction. No. Why did I buy such a big box of Twinkies?

Okay, Twinkie number six. It's making me feel worse. No, I can't. I can't, I can't, I can't.

Okay, I've gargled and come to terms with my sense of shame. That last Twinkie had a negative marginal utility of -10. It made me feel worse. I feel less good about Twinkies than I did at the beginning of this segment.

Let's take a look at what happens to my marginal utility as I consumed more Twinkies. The first Twinkie brought me the greatest amount of satisfaction, 40 utils, because I was hungry and I hadn't had Twinkies for quite some time. Each subsequent Twinkie continues to bring me satisfaction (at least the second and third and fourth ones did), but that additional satisfaction, the marginal utility, is decreasing with each additional Twinkie. This is what we refer to as the law of diminishing marginal utility, which states that as you consume more of a good, the additional satisfaction, or the marginal utility, of consuming each subsequent unit decreases.

It's easy to see how this works with things like food, right? The first thing that you eat when you're very hungry brings you the greatest satisfaction, and with each additional unit that you consume, obviously, as you get more full, there'll be less satisfaction. But this holds true for many goods, almost all goods. So for example, cars. What is the benefit to a household of getting their first car? I mean, it's huge, right? You don't have to take the bus anywhere, you don't have to ride your bike, you can now, like, drive to work. Okay, what is the marginal utility to a household of the second car? It's still big, right? Now Mom and Dad can go two different places at the same time. But definitely, the additional utility of the second car is not as much as that of the first car. So a household could continue to buy more and more cars, but, like, really, what additional value to normal households is that ninth or 10th car bringing, right? The same is true for clothes, right? That first pair of clothes that you buy is huge. Now you can go outside and not get arrested. Awesome, right? The second pair of clothing that you buy: also pretty big. It's like, now I can wash my first pair of clothing, and I don't have to be naked while I'm waiting for it to dry, right? But clearly not as important as the first pair of clothing, right? As you keep buying clothes, at some point, right, like, what value is that 500th t-shirt really bringing you at all?

Okay, so if Twinkies are free, how many Twinkies do I want to consume? As a rational thinker, I want to maximize my total utility, or the total satisfaction I get from eating all of the Twinkies that I consume. The first Twinkie that I consume gives me 40 utils of marginal utility, so the total utility of eating just one Twinkie would be 40 utils of happiness. If I consume a second Twinkie, that second Twinkie brings me an additional 30 utils of happiness. So when I consume two Twinkies, I get a total of 40 utils from the first and 30 from the second, for 70 utils of total happiness from consuming two Twinkies. I get 90 utils of happiness from consuming three Twinkies, and I get 100 utils of happiness from consuming four Twinkies. Five Twinkies also gives me 100 utils of happiness, because that fifth Twinkie doesn't actually increase or decrease my well-being. And if I consume six, like I did, regretfully so, then my happiness actually goes down with the sixth, back down to a total utility of 90. If my goal is to maximize my total utility, then I should continue to consume Twinkies as long as my marginal utility is greater than zero. As long as each additional Twinkie is increasing my happiness by some amount, then I should keep eating Twinkies. In this very personal example of marginal utility, the optimal quantity of Twinkies to consume would have been four or five, but definitely not six. Why did I eat six?

But in the real world, Twinkies are not free, and I'm not talking about the potential guilt or artery-clogging capabilities; I mean you have to actually pay for them. To better understand consumption decisions when we need to actually pay for the good, we need to introduce the closely related idea of marginal benefit. Marginal benefit, like marginal utility, seeks to measure the additional satisfaction or happiness that you get from consuming one more unit of a good. The key difference is that marginal utility uses this hypothetical measure of utils, which doesn't really give us any sense of the dollar value of the happiness that this thing is bringing us. Marginal benefit attempts to measure largely the same thing, the happiness you get from a good, but now we're going to try to place a dollar value on that happiness.

So, going back to my original marginal utility chart here: that first Twinkie gave me 40 utils of satisfaction. If I had to put a dollar value on the happiness or satisfaction that I got from that first Twinkie, we could say maybe I got $4 of happiness. We're going to call this $4 the marginal benefit I gained from the first Twinkie. The second Twinkie brought me happiness, but less satisfaction than the first; let's say $3 of happiness from the second Twinkie. The third Twinkie made me $2 happier. The fourth Twinkie made me $1 happier. The fifth Twinkie didn't make me any happier, and it didn't make me any worse off, so we'll say that the marginal benefit of the fifth Twinkie was $0. And that sixth Twinkie actually made me feel worse; it made me feel, let's say, $1 worse. So this table represents the marginal benefit of consuming each additional Twinkie, and just like marginal utility, we see that marginal benefit decreases as each additional Twinkie is consumed. The difference is that now we're measuring it in dollars rather than utils.

We can also represent this table graphically. Here, we can put marginal benefit on this axis and quantity on this axis. The first Twinkie brings me $4 of happiness: the marginal benefit of the first Twinkie is $4. The second Twinkie has a marginal benefit of $3. $2 of marginal benefit for the third Twinkie. The fourth Twinkie has $1 of marginal benefit, and the fifth Twinkie has a marginal benefit of zero. We can call this thing the marginal benefit curve, and it shows me the additional benefit, in dollar terms, that I get from each subsequent Twinkie.

If the price of Twinkies in the market is $4, would I be willing to buy one Twinkie? Absolutely, right? I'm definitely going to be willing to pay $4 for something that makes me $4 happier. But am I going to pay $4 to buy the second Twinkie, which has a marginal benefit of only $3? No, right? I'm a rational thinker. I'm never going to pay $4 for something that only makes me $3 happier. So if the price of Twinkies is $4, I'll buy one Twinkie. If the price of Twinkies falls to $3, am I going to be willing to buy this first Twinkie? Sure, I mean, that's great. I would love to pay $3 for something that is making me $4 happier. Definitely. Okay, and will I buy the second Twinkie? Sure, I'll pay $3, if I'm a rational thinker, for something that's making me $3 better off. But I'm not going to pay $3 for that third Twinkie, because it only makes me $2 happier. So if the price of Twinkies is $3, I will buy two Twinkies. If the price of Twinkies is $2, I'll buy three Twinkies, because the marginal benefit of that third Twinkie is $2. If the price is $1, I'll buy four Twinkies. And if Twinkies are free, I'll buy and consume five Twinkies, and I'll stop there, because I'm a rational thinker.

So this curve here, which we're calling the marginal benefit curve, is also somehow showing us the quantity of Twinkies that I'm going to buy at different prices, assuming that I'm going to be willing to buy a Twinkie as long as the price is less than or equal to the marginal benefit of consuming that Twinkie. But what is that? A curve that shows us the quantity of Twinkies that I'll buy at different prices? That's just the demand curve! OMG, the demand curve is the marginal benefit curve!

Also, when we call it the marginal benefit curve, we read it like this: if I consume three Twinkies, the marginal benefit of that third Twinkie is $2. The additional satisfaction I got from just that third Twinkie was $2. When we call it the demand curve, we read it like this: if the price is $2, then I will buy three Twinkies. But these two concepts are inextricably intertwined. Why do I buy three Twinkies when the price is $2? Because the third Twinkie brought me $2 of marginal benefit. So this is all going to become very important when we talk about consumer surplus and allocative efficiency in a subsequent video.

Okay, a quick recap of today's topics. Marginal utility is the additional happiness or satisfaction that one gains from consuming one more unit of a good. The law of diminishing marginal utility states that as you consume more of a good, the additional utility, the additional satisfaction gained from each subsequent unit, decreases, just like it did with Twinkies and me. If goods are free, people will continue to consume a good as long as marginal utility is positive, because this will maximize their total utility. Marginal benefit, like marginal utility, measures the additional benefit or satisfaction from consuming a good, but using dollars rather than utils as the unit of measure. Like marginal utility, marginal benefit decreases as more of a good is consumed. Consumers will buy a good as long as price is less than or equal to the marginal benefit of consuming that good. For this reason, the demand curve is the marginal benefit curve.

Okay, next video, we're going to look at a concept called marginal cost, and try to at least partially explain why the supply curve is, in fact, a marginal cost curve. I'll see you there.

UNIT 2 More in Supply and Demand